QA - The neglected savior

The QA is the last link in the development chain and it is usually approached as "we will figure it out when we get there". If not overlooked, the QA can become the engine that drives the project to the end of the race.

Despite the differences specific to each company, a planning for a new project is split into several stages: concept, pre-production, production and post launch. Each company comes with its own definitions and criteria for each stage but generally all pass through these 4.

In the last part of the production stage, all project managers add a QA section. There is usually a benchmark planning for each project, from AAA titles with 6-12 months of QA to small projects with 1-2 weeks of QA.

Of course, the focus is on the project development which occupies the biggest part of the timeline. Most producers underestimate the importance and the added value a good QA can bring and QA is mostly considered a cost, if not a burden.

The QA is the last link in the development chain and it is usually approached as "we will figure it out when we get there" or "we would probably test this by ourselves if needed" or „we have very good developers that work clean, I don’t think we will need much QA”.

But there are experienced producers that understand the importance of QA and includes it also in the development part in different stages and forms: dev testers, tool testers or simply QA advisors.

Dev testers become level design or design advisors giving pertinent feedback on Gameplay, UI/UX or balancing. Some, even prefer the Associate Producers path as they become information hubs regarding the scope of the project.

Tool testers become info designers, level designers or even tool programmers.

Since the time the QA starts on a project it can give the producers all the information regarding the stage of the development including:

- tools development and readiness for mass production

- clear overview of build delivery process which will be crucial towards the end of the project

- team velocity and error prone

- UI/UX, FPS and game play reports

- the probability of reaching the final milestone and more

All the above can be considered or neglected which is translated into time and budget gain or loss.

I've been working on both sides of the development process and the temptation to overlook QA is high. There are simply too many variables to take care of so, as in the planning process, QA is left behind.

There is also a temptation to look for the cheapest solutions in regards to the QA process:

-         „Plan just 1-2 QA passes just to make sure we did not miss anything”

-         „Get low cost QA company to decrease the total cost of the project”

-         „Just put some juniors to make some walkthroughs, that should suffice”

Sounds familiar?

If not handled properly, the QA process can be very costly for the project. If released with big issues, the reviews will be poor and the users will be unhappy and ask for refunds. This will generate the need of extra development: quality patches, DLCs, etc, which is translated to money loss.

When a project is released with a negative buzz, it will be very hard to get the players back to it and even to other games from the same company.

If not overlooked, the QA can become the engine that drives the project to the end of the race, but there are some certain conditions for this to happen:

- The planning should be made together with a QA responsible that understands the concept

- QA people are integrated as early as possible in the project

.......Ow, and there was one last one: the QA team needs to be damn good!

Latest Jobs

Cryptic Studios

Senior Producer

Anne Arundel Community College

Arnold, MD, USA
Instructor/Assistant Professor, Game Art

Night School Studio

Los Angeles, CA, USA
Level Designer / Scripter, Games Studio
More Jobs   


Explore the
Subscribe to
Follow us

Game Developer Job Board

Game Developer Newsletter


Explore the

Game Developer Job Board

Browse open positions across the game industry or recruit new talent for your studio

Subscribe to

Game Developer Newsletter

Get daily Game Developer top stories every morning straight into your inbox

Follow us


Follow us @gamedevdotcom to stay up-to-date with the latest news & insider information about events & more