Self-confrontation, cloud testing, paper prototypes: The new faces of playtests

Two new trends are emerging in playtesting: Their integration very early in the development cycle and the multiplication of their formats, from the most economical to the most expensive and complex. Let's review three formats that illustrate these trends

No one ignores the importance of playtests and the majority of studios integrate them into their development cycle. Traditional formats are still relevant, but two new trends are emerging: The integration of playtests very early in the development cycle and the multiplication of their formats, from the most economical to the most expensive and complex. Let's review three formats that illustrate these trends.

I set up and managed the playtest structure of the Ubisoft studio in Annecy where the multiplayer modes of Splinter Cell - Pandora Tomorrow and Chaos Theory were developed. As a game designer, I very quickly apprehended the immense effectiveness of playtests to improve the experience of the players but also to improve the work of the game designers themselves. Since that time, I have continued to follow this field and have had the opportunity to discover, through my clients' consulting assignments, three new ways to conduct playtests.

Self-confrontation - Understanding what's going on in players' minds is essential to building a good game experience. Questioning them while they're playing is not the best way to do it, because they are then focused on the action. And do it after their game session is not because the players are no longer in the context. Self-confrontational techniques, derived from analytical methods in occupational psychology, provide a better solution. Individual self-confrontation consists first of all in letting a player play but in filming his gaming experience and, if possible, the player himself. Then, the video is replayed in front of the latter and the person in charge of the session asks questions when the filmed sequence shows a hesitation, frustration or on the contrary a flash of pleasure. This playtest technique can be used right from the prototype stage and can be applied to a large number of themes to study: Gameplay, menu navigation, controls, navigation in an open world.

Cloud testing - Good playtests require ... good playtesters, players that match your target, available and in sufficient numbers. How to find them when one is a small studio? Cloud testing involves testing a game by a community of players. For a team developing a mobile game, the most economical solution is to build a community that follows its development and offer its members to test an advanced version of the game through app like Testflight (iOS) or HockeyApp (iOS and Android). But if you want to target your playtesters, sites offers this type of service: PlaytestCloud, GBTN (Global Test Network Beta), Stardust Testing, etc. They are mostly paying but they offer many advantages: profiling of the playtesters, choice of the country and of platform, follow-up of the results. Cloud testing allows small organizations to run playtest campaigns that only large studios could afford before.

Paper prototypes - The sooner you go about evaluating a game concept, the less expensive it is to correct the weak points. Let's not forget that the evaluation of a concept also covers its potential to attract players. A paper prototype makes it possible to evaluate many aspects of a concept before even writing the first line of code. It is simply a simulacrum game developed with a presentation software like Powerpoint or Keynotes. We can present to a panel of players a representation of the game experience, including the graphic style, the sound environment, the main and secondary gameplays, navigation and menus. Of course, a paper prototype is not suitable for all genres and its degree of interactivity is low, but it allows to test the attractiveness of a concept for a very limited budget and in a few weeks. Zynga used this format to test concepts and I personally developed one for a client. The feedback from the playtesters was very useful for correcting several aspects of the design.


My previous blog entries:

Is there life after Fortnite? An emerging trend in game design brings novelty

Game design: Lesson to learn from the 2019 BAFTA best mobile game award

Quantitative design - How to define XP thresholds?  FEATURED BLOG


Pascal Luban

Creative director & game designer, freelance

24+ years of experience serving studios and publishers


Picture credit: Urupong

Latest Jobs

Cryptic Studios

Senior Producer

Anne Arundel Community College

Arnold, MD, USA
Instructor/Assistant Professor, Game Art

Night School Studio

Los Angeles, CA, USA
Level Designer / Scripter, Games Studio
More Jobs   


Explore the
Subscribe to
Follow us

Game Developer Job Board

Game Developer Newsletter


Explore the

Game Developer Job Board

Browse open positions across the game industry or recruit new talent for your studio

Subscribe to

Game Developer Newsletter

Get daily Game Developer top stories every morning straight into your inbox

Follow us


Follow us @gamedevdotcom to stay up-to-date with the latest news & insider information about events & more