[This week, our partnership with game criticism site Critical Distance brings us picks from Ian Miles Cheong on topics including thoughts on the Portal 2 ARG and how perspective affects immersion.
Welcome to another fine edition of This Week in Videogame Criticism, where we curate the most interesting articles in the critical blogosphere for you to peruse and enjoy. Though whether this week’s edition is truly "fine" is something better left for you to judge, dear reader.
The first article to grace this week’s edition is Adam Ruch's
piece on the immersion of first- and third-person games
in Kotaku Australia.
He writes, "My issue lies somewhere in between the concept of immersion and character-identification, which aren’t exactly the same thing. The two are related, and reinforce each other, but can also operate independently and in different ways."
"The first way, the ‘common wisdom’ is repeated in game design manuals and states that first-person perspective is more immersive and makes the player feel more like they are the character in the game.
Also on Kotaku, Mark Serrels wrote a two-part article
quest to obtain 50 street pass hits in one day with his newly acquired Nintendo 3DS.
Elsewhere on the internet, contributing writers to Kill Screen review a few of their favorite fatalities
in Mortal Kombat
. Kirk Hamilton also wrote an article on Paste Magazine on the subject of genres and classifications
He Writes, "Videogames certainly present all sorts of unique challenges when it comes to genre; to start with, they exist across a wide enough experiential spectrum that even the simplest ones require multiple types of classification. We must take into account how a game looks, its setting, and if applicable, the type of story it is trying to tell. But first and foremost, a game's genre must describe how it plays, the ways in which we can expect to interact with it.
Also on Paste is Sinan Kubba’s article on what went wrong with Mirror’s Edge
, and how to fix it
. Returning to the subject of genres, K. Cox shares her thoughts—or meditations—on the adventure game
, a genre long maligned for its strict linearity.
Matt Weise writes about "The Sublime Joy of Flight
" for the MIT Gambit Lab, in which he shares his experience with Pilotwings Resort
and relates it to his love of flying games. Johannes Koski continues his investigation into the women of Liberty City
on the Border House. The article is part two of a three-part series.
On his blog Dubious Quality, Bill Harris writes about a storm that’s currently brewing
in the game industry, which should give everyone something to worry about. According to the post, game publishers are attempting to starve the traditional games press out of business in an effort to "control the message" about their products as much, and as often as possible.
Jorge Albor of the Experience Points blog has a few words to share
on the launch of Portal 2
’s ARG, which lead up to the release of the game. He writes, "The marketing stunt, if we can call it that, is unsettling, at least personally, because it fires a spotlight on the cultural power differential between the development studio and its player fan base.
On Zang.org, William Huber writes about "critical gamification
," and the recent trend of "gamification," which is quickly becoming a part of marketing buzzspeak, and how critics can deal with it.
Wrapping up this week’s edition of TWIVGB is a piece by Paul Bauman, who rarely updates his Iterations of Cid blog. He's written a piece on Earth Reborn
, a new board game that manages to provide meaningful experiences through strategy elements
in its gameplay.