5 takeaways from Gabe Newell's Reddit Q&A on paid mods

Some choice quotes from Newell's Reddit Q&A that help shed light on what Valve hopes to achieve by allowing modders to sell their work -- and how it fits into the company's long-term goals for Steam.

Late last week Valve updated Steam to allow game mod creators to sell their work for real money on the Steam Workshop, starting with Skyrim mods. Revenue from those sales is now split between Valve, the modder and the game's creator/publisher, who is also responsible for determining the modder's cut. 

Many people took to various corners of the Internet to express their concerns about the whole thing, which include the potential for free mod communities to wither if publishers move to prevent mods for their games from being distributed anywhere but the Steam Workshop. More than a few game developers argued that allowing modders to charge for their work was a good idea, and on Saturday Valve frontman Gabe Newell opened a Reddit thread to answer select questions from the community about the whole mess.

This isn't the first time Newell has outlined his goals for Valve and Steam on Reddit, and everything he says should be taken with a grain of salt -- a year ago he admitted (again, on Reddit) that "iterating with the community," as Valve aims to do, "your near-term objectives change all the time."

However, his comments over the weekend help shed light on what Valve hopes to achieve by allowing modders to sell their work (beyond its cut of the revenue, of course) and how it fits into the company's long-term goals. The full comment thread is worth reading, but for your convenience we've embedded some choice quotes below.

Some folks are making more money selling their work on Steam Workshop than they might in traditional game development, and Valve wants to encourage that

We've long known that a lot of money is passing through Steam Workshop, and Newell reiterated the company's emphasis on pricing mods in his comments this weekend.

Comment from discussion MODs and Steam.

Valve doesn't want to tell game/mod makers what to do -- it wants the community to do it with their wallets

When the representative of a high-profile Skyrim mod community website asked Newell whether or not Valve would take steps to ensure that Steam Workshop doesn't knock the legs out of the game modding community by, say, preventing publishers from requiring all mods for their games to be sold through Steam, Newell demured. 
Comment from discussion MODs and Steam.

Later in the same conversation, the Valve frontman commented that Steam shies away from telling content creators how to use the service because "everything outrages somebody" and "it's a lot more tractable and customer/creator friendly to focus on building systems that connect customers to the right content for them."  

Revenue from sales of mods has already passed the five-figure mark

While responding to a question about why Valve didn't just implement a donation system for mods, Newell noted that Skyrim mod sales revenue had already surpassed $10k in roughly two days. 

Comment from discussion MODs and Steam.

Valve thinks ripoffs and copycats will be stopped by community policing

Paid Skyrim mods have only been avaible for a few days, and there have already been multiple reported instances of people stealing the work of others and selling it as a mod on the Steam Workshop. 
Ripoffs and copycats are rampant in the mobile game market, but Newell believes that Steam will be different; he expects that both Valve and the community at large will be able to effectively police the Steam Workshop.
Comment from discussion MODs and Steam.

Steam Greenlight and customer support are busted -- and Valve knows it

People love to complain about Steam having poor customer service -- Valve currently bears an "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau because of it.

At the same time, its Greenlight initiative effectively torpedoed discoverability for most developers in 2012, driving the company to try and make good by (among other things) launching a Steam Curator system and revamping the entire storefront with its Discovery update.

This weekend Newell acknowledged that both issues were "legitimate beefs" and noted that Valve is continuing to sort out how to make things right.

Comment from discussion MODs and Steam.

Latest Jobs

Pocketwatch Games

Senior Gameplay Engineer


Cambridge, Massachusetts
Jr. Programmer

Gameloft Australia

Brisbane, Australia
Creative Director

Sucker Punch Productions

Bellevue, Washington
Senior Systems Designer
More Jobs   


Register for a
Subscribe to
Follow us

Game Developer Account

Game Developer Newsletter


Register for a

Game Developer Account

Gain full access to resources (events, white paper, webinars, reports, etc)
Single sign-on to all Informa products

Subscribe to

Game Developer Newsletter

Get daily Game Developer top stories every morning straight into your inbox

Follow us


Follow us @gamedevdotcom to stay up-to-date with the latest news & insider information about events & more